Manhua vs. Manhwa vs. Manga: Key Differences Every Fan Should Know
If you have ever been a comics fan, chances are you are familiar with ‘Manga.’ Those interested in manga may have come across the terms Manhua and Manhwa. While the terms Manhua, Manhwa, and Manga may sound similar, they have some important differences. Some may confuse those with Japanese Manga, but they are their South Korean and Chinese counterparts.
The evolution of Asian comics has brought Manga, Manhwa, and Manhua into a new generation. Webtoons and graphic novels continue to gain popularity across the world, connecting readers through diverse stories and art styles. Still scratching your head over these terms? Worry no more, as this blog aims to discuss the key differences between them and focus on readability, layout, and art style.
This blog explores the differences between these comics so comic fans can learn about the unique qualities of each type. If you are a fan, this blog will help you discover the differences between Manga, Manhua, and Manhwa and what sets them apart.
What is Manga?
Manga is Japanese comics that can be traced back to the 1200s. The contemporary manga style art started gaining traction post-World War 2 in 1945, often described as Japan’s creative renaissance period. While manga doesn’t need an introduction, it tops the list of Asian graphic novels and has the largest global fanbase and popularity, with Dragon Ball Z as its most popular comic and animated series.
In Japanese, the term manga refers to involuntary pictures or fanciful imaginations. However, after the introduction of manga, it became one of the most popular and artistic comic styles. With its origin in Japan, Manga is often created in black and white, reflecting traditional Japanese manga art styles and detailed characters that influence graphic novels and anime globally.
Most of the anime shows today are adapted versions of manga, which further fuels its reputation. Given the popularity and reputation of manga, they have been translated into English, among other languages, for global reach. Besides, there are some unofficial translations available of manga.
Just because manga is monochrome doesn’t mean it looks dull. Manga art styles are detailed and powerful, which makes them more impressive than colored graphics. Manga storytelling, on the other hand, adds to the comics. Believe it or not, there’s manga for everyone. From traditional manga format often mistaken for sci-fi, action, adventure, gore, and fantasy, there’s something for everyone as they also have comedy, romance, history, reincarnation, etc. genre storylines.
The length of the animated series varies from 100 to 1000 episodes. Some manga series exceed over 1000 episodes and are still going. Manga fans prefer traditional manga format in print form. However, it’s also available across multiple digital comics platforms and websites, making it easily accessible.
What is Manhwa
Originating in South Korea, the history of manhwa dates to the 1930s and 40s when it was published for the first time in the Hangeul language and has evolved in recent years into webtoons, a digital comic format known for its full color and vertical scrolling style. Not as popular as Manga, Korean webtoons are gaining popularity with manhwa. When it comes to Korean webtoon vs Manga, Manhwa has simplistic language with little nuances, making manhwa more decent than its counterparts. Additionally, Korean translators translate manhwa projects officially and non-officially, adding to its reputation.
As opposed to Japanese and Chinese comics, the manhwa art style is fully colored, making it look epic and robust. Manhwa’s art style reflects action fluidity and dynamics, making it challenging to follow every move. Regarding manhwa genres and themes, they are not as varied as those of manga but do well in action scenes. The focus of the manhwa comics is on action-packed scenes – how they are executed, including dynamics behind each strike, movements, and motions. Unlike manga and manhua, the actions of manhwa do the talking, and there is limited emphasis on conversation.
Manhwa art format is suitable for a mobile device as it is read from top to bottom. With little text and more action involved, it doesn’t require zooming in the pictures on mobile devices, which increases its accessibility. The most popular manhua series is Solo Leveling, which is an 8-volume book series and, overall, 14 novels. Manhwa webtoons also started gaining traction after its launch in January 2024, and the second season will be released in January 2025.
What is Manhua?
Originating in China in 1904, manhua was first published in a Shanghai-based newspaper, which later supported the creation of Shanghai Sketch in 1928 – a weekly pictorial magazine. Manhua refers to Chinese comics that often incorporate the traditional Chinese language and focus on Wuxia and Xinxia themes. It features martial art styles integrated in cultural stories and is rich in fantasy elements.
As manga has global recognition, including the Western hemisphere, manhua tops the Asian comic industry only, with Chinese-speaking communities preferring it over others, limiting its appeal. When it comes to Manhua vs. Manhwa vs. Manga, the most challenging comic type to translate is manhua. Even if translated, the language is often wordier than the original text, necessitating formatting and layout expertise to present globally.
There are also differences in comic culture. Chinese comics, manhua, reflect culture through Chinese slang terms, terminologies, and proverbs, which are often unseen in other art types. One common feature between manhwa and manhua is that they are colored, while the latter uses water coloring, in contrast to manhwa, which emphasizes movements.
A drawback that affects the reputation and popularity of manhua is that the martial arts fight scenes can be repetitive. This is also reflected in their popular manhua series Soul Buster, which is based on a romantic novel of the 14th Century that garnered average reviews owing to some uninteresting characters. While some series may be boring, there are also some gems you can find after digging.
Key Differences Manga vs Manhwa vs Manhua
1. Origin and Language
Although there are significant differences between content types, art, and popularity. The main difference between manga, manhwa, and manhua lies in their origin, language, and artistic style. Manga originates from Japan, manhwa from Korea, and manhua from China. They all represent the Asian comics industry with manga dominating print books while manhwa and manhua comics thrive in the digital comic space.
2. Cultural Differences
Regarding cultural differences, manhua holds traditional Chinese martial arts and language nuances. On the other hand, manga is inclined toward supernatural stories and fantasy, and Manhwa has storylines that depict Korean beauty culture more realistically.
3. Art Styles
Regarding the art style, manhwa’s Solo Leveling is relatable to the Japanese genre, and Manhua’s introduction of Chinese martial arts relates to manga’s fantasy. Even some of the manga novels have also explored some Chinese novels, which makes all of them relatable to some extent. While Japanese manga is well-known for its shounen and shoujo genres, Manhwa explores modern, relatable stories, and manhua often brings epic series based on ancient Chinese language and mythology to life.
4. Representation and Readability
A key difference is that manga is typically black and white, while manhwa and manhua often use full color, especially in webtoons, for a more modern format. They also represent different writing styles, where manhua and manga are read from top to bottom and right to left, respectively; manhwa adopts European and American comic approaches starting from left to right. In digital comics, the layouts are often from top to bottom, making it easier to access and scroll.
In print, manga is difficult to depict movements, whereas manhwa and manhua adopt a vertical layout to depict the movement of their objects. This allows manhwa to display unique aesthetics compared to other comic sources.
5. Character Designs
With manga published in black and white, some special releases are printed on colored pages. Similarly, manhwa is also traditionally printed in black and white, but the digital version is published in color. The same holds true for digital manhua, which is published in color. The digital versions of the manga were inspired by Walt Disney art, with characters having small mouths, big eyes, and exaggerated expressions. On the other hand, manhwa and manhua focus on more realistic human appearances and proportions.
Summing Up the Differences Between Manga, Manhua and Manhwa
The previous sections detail the major differences between each comic type and artistic cultures. This section focuses on summarizing those differences in tabular form.
Characteristic | Manga | Manhwa | Manhua |
Origin | Japan | Korea | China |
Art style | Exaggerating features with bold lines and dynamics | Detailed and realistic features, incorporating elements of Western comics | Often uses bright colors and intricate designs with significant variations |
Reading Pattern | Right to Left and Top to Bottom | Left to Right | Right to Left and Top to Bottom |
Storytelling | Typically rooted in the fantastical or supernatural, this genre tackles serious and complex themes. | This genre frequently explores social issues, drama, love, and relationships among other mature subjects. | Adopts a variety of forms from historical fiction to comedy, romance, drama, and Chinese martial arts with a wide range of storytelling. |
Readership | Appealing to a wide range of readers, regardless of age or gender. | It is enjoyed by readers of all ages and genders, it is often regarded as more mature than manga. | Widely popular among readers of all ages and genders in China, and its reach is expanding globally. |
Popular Series | Dragon Ball Z | Solo Leveling | Soul Buster |
Ready To Publish Your Anime or Comic Book Masterpiece?
Now that you are still with us and aspiring to publish your own anime or comic book, eBookologist have your back from ghostwriting to publishing. If you have started writing your comic book, our self-publishing support services can be handy. With us on your side, you can step into the world of anime and share your masterpiece with hassle-free publishing services. We have experts to work closely with you from brainstorming ideas to publishing and marketing. We are a one-stop solution for all your publishing needs.
Wrapping Up
The blog dives into the anime world, discussing key differences between manga, manhwa, and manhua. Our discussion revealed that these comics differ in their art styles, reflecting unique differences in culture and storytelling traditions. A key difference is that manga is typically black and white, while manhwa and manhua often use full color, especially in webtoons for a more modern format. While they have profound differences, they are popular across the globe, with manga leading the Asian comics industry.
In recent years, manhwa has also started gaining popularity, with webtoons dominating digital comic platforms, whereas manga remains rooted in traditional print books and graphic novels. However, in digital print, manga and manhwa have higher popularity across the globe than manhua—Chinese comics reflecting their culture and language nuances.
Frequently Asked Questions:
Q1. What’s the difference between Manga, Manhwa, and Manhua?
Manga comes from Japan. It’s usually in black and white and is read from right to left. Manhwa is from South Korea. It’s often fully colored when online and is read from left to right. Manhua is from China. It often has bright colors and detailed designs and is read from right to left.
Q2. Why is Manga more popular worldwide than Manhwa and Manhua?
Manga has been known internationally for a longer time, partly because of its connection to popular anime shows like Dragon Ball Z and Naruto. Its wide range of stories, detailed artwork, and availability in both print and digital forms make it easier for people around the world to enjoy.
Q3. Which types of stories are more popular in Manhwa and Manhua compared to Manga?
Manga has many different types of stories, like fantasy, science fiction, romance, and action. Manhwa usually talks about social problems, relationships, and exciting action parts. Manhua is famous for its stories about martial arts, history, and things from Chinese culture.
Q4. What makes the art in Manga, Manhwa, and Manhua look different?
Manga often shows big emotions with funny faces and strong lines. Manhwa uses ideas from Western comics and has detailed, realistic characters. Manhua likes to use bright colors, fancy designs, and shows cultural ideas.
Book Design Services
Crafting visually stunning and reader-friendly layouts for your book.